THE DATA-DRIVEN CASE FOR A/B TESTING YOUR PROFESSIONAL HEADSHOT.

The Data-Driven Case for A/B Testing Your Professional Headshot.

The Data-Driven Case for A/B Testing Your Professional Headshot.

Blog Article

In the world of digital marketing, A/B testing is a non negotiable practice. We test headlines, button colours, and ad copy to optimize for the highest possible conversion rates. We would never leave the performance of these critical assets to guesswork. Yet, when it comes to one of the most important assets on a professional’s key platform, their LinkedIn profile picture most people simply pick the photo they personally like best and leave it for years.

This is a significant strategic error. Your professional headshot is not just a picture; it is a critical piece of marketing creative that has a measurable impact on your engagement, your networking success, and your ability to build client trust. Just like any other creative asset, its performance can and should be tested.

Making a data driven decision about which headshot to use is the final step in a truly professional branding process. A premier service like HERO SHOT provides a variety of strategically crafted images from a single photoshoot session, giving you the perfect material to conduct a meaningful A/B test. This guide makes the case for why you should be testing your headshot and how to do it effectively.

Why Your Gut Instinct is Often Wrong


The headshot you like the most is often not the one that performs the best. Our personal preferences are clouded by self perception and insecurities. You might dislike a photo because you think your smile looks slightly crooked, but that same subtle imperfection might be what makes you look more authentic and trustworthy to a stranger.

Conversely, a photo you love because it feels powerful and authoritative might come across as intimidating or unapproachable to your target audience. The only way to know for sure is to remove your personal bias and let the data speak for itself. You are not the target audience for your own headshot. Your potential clients, employers, and network connections are.

The Key Metrics: What Are We Actually Testing For?


When A/B testing a headshot, we are not measuring which photo gets the most compliments from friends. We are measuring its effectiveness against specific business goals. The most common platform for this is LinkedIn, where your headshot has a direct impact on several key performance indicators (KPIs).

  • Profile View Rate: Does a particular headshot make people more likely to click on your profile when they see you in a search result or a feed? This is a primary measure of your photo's stopping power.

  • Connection Request Acceptance Rate: When you send a connection request, does one headshot result in a higher acceptance rate than another? This metric is a powerful indicator of how trustworthy and approachable your image appears.

  • InMail/Message Response Rate: If you are using LinkedIn for sales or outreach, the response rate to your messages can be influenced by your profile picture. A photo that projects warmth and credibility can lead to more replies.

  • Perceived Competence and Influence: While harder to quantify with a simple metric, tools like Photofeeler allow you to get anonymous feedback on how competent, likeable, and influential you appear in different photos.


The A/B Test Framework: How to Test Your Headshots


A successful A/B test requires a methodical approach. During a strategic personal branding photoshoot, you should aim to capture several distinct variations of your headshot specifically for this purpose.

The Essential Headshot Variations to Test


A comprehensive session with a service like HERO SHOT can provide you with a range of options. The most valuable test compares different expressions and moods.

  1. The Warm and Approachable Headshot: This features a genuine, open mouthed smile that reaches the eyes. This is your rapport builder.

  2. The Confident and Authoritative Headshot: This features a more serious, focused expression, perhaps with a subtle, closed mouth smile. This is your credibility builder.

  3. The Engaged and Thoughtful Headshot: This might be a slightly off camera look or a more dynamic in action style portrait. This can project innovation and intelligence.


Method 1: The LinkedIn Connection Request Test (Manual A/B Test)


This is a simple yet effective way to test your headshots directly on LinkedIn.

  • Step 1: The Setup. Prepare a standardized, personalized connection request message. Create a list of 100 200 target professionals you want to connect with (e.g., potential clients in a specific industry).

  • Step 2: Run Test A. For one week, use Headshot A (e.g., the warm/approachable one) as your profile picture. Send out 50-100 of your standardized connection requests. At the end of the week, record the number of requests sent and the number accepted.

  • Step 3: Run Test B. The following week, change only your profile picture to Headshot B (e.g., the confident/authoritative one). Send out the same number of requests to a similar group of professionals from your list. Record the number sent and accepted.

  • Step 4: Analyse the Data. Calculate the acceptance rate for each headshot (Accepted / Sent * 100). The headshot with the statistically significant higher acceptance rate is your winner for building initial trust.


Method 2: The Photofeeler Test (Crowdsourced Feedback)


For faster, qualitative feedback, platforms like Photofeeler are invaluable.

  • Step 1: The Setup. Upload your top 2-3 headshot variations to the platform.

  • Step 2: Get Anonymous Feedback. The platform will show your photos to a large pool of anonymous users who will rate them on three key business traits: Competence, Likeability, and Influence.

  • Step 3: Analyse the Scores. You will receive detailed scores for each photo. You might find that one photo scores highest on Likeability while another scores highest on Competence. This data allows you to choose the headshot that best aligns with your primary career goal. If you are in a sales or coaching role, likeability might be most important. If you are a CEO or lawyer, competence might be the priority.


A Testimony to Getting a Variety of Shots


Wow, the reviews weren’t wrong. Thoroughly enjoyed this experience and the way the photographer worked with me on the composition and gave honest, respectful direction. Thoroughly recommend trying a few different outfits in different poses. I received a massive amount of frames to choose from. Will definitely go back when I need new shots.

Dan Fische

Final Thoughts: From a Personal Preference to a Strategic Decision


Your professional headshot is too important to be chosen based on a whim. By applying the same data driven principles you use in other areas of your business, you can transform your choice from a subjective guess into a strategic decision. A/B testing empowers you to select the image that will most effectively help you achieve your professional goals. A great photoshoot provides the ammunition; a smart A/B test tells you which weapon to use.

Report this page